After a promising start in the first week’s eliminations, I thought last week was a little bit of a letdown (although I did predict 2 out of the bottom 3 again). I didn’t think Ashley or Max should have gone home — I would have sent home Caitlin (her technique isn’t any different than Kayla’s, imo) and Kupono (based on his lackluster hip hop performance and solo).
On to this week! Toni Basil is the guest judge. Her comments about “street” make me want to throw something at the TV so I fast-forwarded every time she opened her mouth. It’s too bad — I admire her dance and choreography career but she goes on and on and on during her critiques and doesn’t even really say anything constructive or helpful.
LOVED
Melissa and Ade – They’ve been OMGSOGOOD these past 3 weeks. And this rumba was fantastic. They got the hip movements and emotions down… their angles were gorgeous, lifts steady… I think they’ve just become my favorite couple.
Janette and Brandon – I haven’t been overly impressed with them so far but they totally killed this hip hop routine. Especially Brandon. I was not expecting him to be so good! It was energetic and fun — definitely my favorite of the night. WOW.
LIKED
Kayla and Kupono – A solid Viennese waltz. Very “dreamy” and ethereal feeling. But is it just me or was that routine really short? It felt like there were more tricks and lifts than actual waltzing.
Randi and Evan – The concept of this contemporary routine is pretty ridiculous but it worked. They were cute and performed it well. No complaints here.
Jeanine and Philip – Jeanine really shined in this Broadway performance. Philip’s lucky that the routine relied heavily on personality because he definitely lacks technique. Overall, though, they sold it.
EHHH
Karla and Jonathan – This Dave Scott hip hop was SO. DISAPPOINTING. First. Jonathan was waaaayyy out of his league. He couldn’t get the steps, he wasn’t in sync with Karla, and he had absolutely no personality. He seems like such a nice guy but SERIOUSLY, he is dragging her down. Poor Karla. I think she’s an amazing dancer but she’s saddled with a below average partner. Second. I really like Dave Scott but I think part of the problem was the choreography. It’s like he put all the effort into Janette and Brandon’s routine and slapped this one together.
Asuka and Vitolio – I didn’t like this jazz routine at all. I normally like Mandy’s choreography but this one didn’t do anything for me at all. A lot of it didn’t seem to flow very well from one step to the other… or maybe it was the dancers, I’m not sure. I actually stopped watching in the middle because Vitolio was so obviously out-dancing Asuka that it made me feel uncomfortable for her. Just like Jonathan, I think she’s out of her element — she’s not a very versatile dancer (yet) and it’s definitely starting to show.
Caitlin and Jason – Even with the dramatic music, I was bored out of my mind with this paso doble. They lacked the power and chemistry needed to pull this off. And it didn’t help that I could see the effort and concentration in their faces.
Predictions for the Bottom 3: Definitely Karla/Jonathan (insert sad face here) and Asuka/Vitolio. I’m wavering back and forth on Caitlin/Jason and Kayla/Kupono for the third spot but I’ll guess Caitlin/Jason. Ideally, I’d like Jonathan and Asuka to go so that would make way for a new couple in Karla/Vitolio…
I was surprised Vitolio/Asuka’s routine got so much praise. It was so bad and so obviously bad on Asuka’s part. And I love love Vitolio so I hope he doesn’t get the boot if Asuka does.
The boys are really weak this season. There are a few exceptions, Ade and Brandon come to mind, but the rest are just not very impressive. To be honest though the first week nearly every couple got a dance in one partner’s style and it created an illusion I think about the dancers this season. Now that many are having to dance outside their style, this seasons dancers are not measuring up to past seasons.
Totally has nothing to do with SYTYCD since I don’t watch it, but I’m sorry I’ve been so lax in commenting! Here are some of my thoughts from your last posts 🙂
That’s so cool you’re going to Australia and the Philippines! I hope you have a great time and take lots of pics to share 😀
I’m glad you told me about the Hangover not being overly woman-friendly! I’m not big on female stereotypes so I probably wouldn’t have cared for it lol.
Diesel is so cute in his Lakers gear! Also, I’m jealous you get to go to Disneyland so often! You’re so lucky.
Off to bed now for me, I’m going to try to comment more often! <3
I totally agree with your entire commentary about this week! Sorry I’m a little late, but I just watched it over the weekend. LOVE Mel & Ade. They’re my favorite couple, and actually have been since the first episode.
I don’t really like Brandon much, but I do have to admit he really did a good job with the hip hop this week. I also reall liked Kayla & Kupono, but mainly for Kayla…I think she’s so pretty when she dances!
Your 3 “Ehhh” couples were spot on! All B3! Did you agree with who went home? I sure did! Jon & Asuka just weren’t bringing it…and now they paid the consequences…